EP317:  Why Most Real Estate Startups Fail (And How to Build One That Actually Makes Money)

APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY

Let’s talk about something a little uncomfortable… but wildly important.

Most real estate startups?

They don’t make it past year one.

And sure — there are a hundred reasons why. Bad market timing. Bad partners. Bad luck.

But we’re going to let you in on the real reason they don’t last.

They aren’t profitable.

Plain and simple.

We know, we know.

➡️ That word — “profit” — doesn’t sound sexy.

Especially when the world is over here flexing how many doors they own, how many commas are in their asset management fees, or how many deals they’ve acquired this year.

But here’s the deal, friend: Profit is the scoreboard.

Profit is the part where your hustle… your risk… your late nights and early flights… actually turn into money you keep.

Not fees.

Not fancy titles.

Not headcount or followers or units.

Profit.

Now before we dive into the exact framework we used to scale from zero to $400 million+ in real estate — we want to take you back to New York City 🗽, to a story that’s part-urban legend, part warning sign.

One that might just change the way you see your business.

The Skyscraper That Almost Took Manhattan Down

In the middle of Manhattan, a gleaming skyscraper known as the Citicorp Center stood tall — modern, bold, iconic.

But behind the scenes?

There was a near-catastrophe hiding in its bones.

Engineers designed it to sit on four stilts, strategically placed around the base to accommodate a historic church.

To make it work, every structural element had to work in harmony: the steel chevrons, the wind bracing system, the internal core. They even installed a giant “tuned mass damper” to keep the building from swaying in storms.

But one tiny change — bolting the chevrons instead of welding them — combined with a missed wind-load calculation, almost brought the whole thing crashing down.

All it took was one overlooked detail, and the entire building — the pride of New York — was suddenly vulnerable.

Because it didn’t matter how strong the other parts were.

If just one system failed, everything else came tumbling with it.

Your Real Estate Business?

It’s Built the Same Way

If you’re building a real estate business that lasts — one that not only looks good on the outside, but performs when the storms hit — then you need more than a solid deal or a good story.

You need four solid pillars.

Miss one? You might not notice right away.
But the cracks will show.
And trust me… you do not want to learn this lesson the hard way.

So let’s talk about what those four pillars are — starting with the one everyone obsesses over (but still tends to get wrong).

Pillar One: The Buy Box

Learning how to invest in real estate is a lot like learning to scuba dive.

Before you’re ever allowed near a coral reef or a sea turtle, you have to learn the basics — like how to breathe underwater.

It’s not glamorous.

It’s not complicated.

But it’s essential.

In real estate, your Buy Box is your first breath underwater.

It’s where everything begins.

For us, back when we were just starting, our Buy Box was… let’s just say, a little fuzzy.

We bought a C-Class property in a less-than-stellar location because it looked like a steal.

But what we didn’t see coming?

The operational headaches.

The challenging tenant base.

The cash flow that looked good on paper but didn’t hold up in real life.

It was like swimming with leaky gear. We got through it, but it took a lot of effort — and a lot of learning.

Now?

Our Buy Box is dialed in.

We focus on prime assets in emerging cities.

We choose locations with job growth, population trends, and economic indicators that point up and to the right.

We buy at prices that leave breathing room — not ones that rely on heroic renovations to make sense.

Because when your Buy Box is strong, everything else gets easier.

But here’s the truth most people won’t tell you:

Even the perfect property won’t save you… if you fund it the wrong way.

Pillar Two: The Capital Stack

If your Buy Box is your oxygen tank, your Capital Stack is your air supply.

It’s not just about raising money — it’s about structuring your capital in a way that aligns with your business plan and your market reality.

When we first started, we thought raising just enough money was fine. Spoiler alert: it wasn’t.

We turned down extra investor capital — thinking, “We’ve got what we need.” And then the interest rate environment changed, fast. Suddenly, we were scrambling.

The truth is, getting the capital right is everything.

It’s about asking:

• Should we go fixed or floating?
• How much runway do we need?
• What kind of reserves should we build in before we ever hit a bump?

We once bought a rate cap for $500,000, thinking we were being smart. Two years later? That same cap renewal cost $1 million.

If we’d planned better upfront, we could’ve saved hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Lesson learned. (The expensive way.)

Pillar Three: Operational Excellence

Here’s a big myth in real estate: That you buy a property and it runs itself. (Insert laugh-cry emoji here.)

Friend, that couldn’t be further from the truth.

Operational excellence isn’t about you being onsite fixing sinks. It’s about building the right team — and leading them like a boss.

For us, that means clear communication. Simple business plans. Strong culture. And never, ever settling for “meh.”

In fact, one of our properties hit a 900+ reputation score (FYI: the national average hovers in the 600s) — because we chose the best management team, aligned on goals, and focused on service.

Why does that matter?

Because great ops equals:

• Higher rents
• Less turnover
• Better tenant experience
• And ultimately? More profit. 🙌

(Yes, we’re circling back to that magic word.)

Pillar Four: Strategic Exit

Most people don’t think about the exit when they buy. But we do. Always.

Because your exit strategy drives your entrance. It shapes how you finance, how you operate, how you create value — and how you protect your downside.

We’ve had deals where we walked away from millions because the timing wasn’t right.

We’ve also had exits that exceeded every projection — because we thought five moves ahead.

You don’t have to get it all perfect.

But you do have to be intentional.

The Bottom Line

You can have the prettiest website, the best acquisition story, and a deal that looks like a dream on Instagram…

But if you’re not building for profit — real, sustainable, long-term wealth — you’re just playing dress-up in a grown-up business.

Profit is the proof.

It’s the outcome of these four pillars working together.

Miss one, and you’re building a tower on sand.

So start where you are.

Audit your pillars.

And build the kind of real estate business that stands tall — and stays standing — no matter what winds come your way.

You’ve got this. 💛